A Butcher’s Guide to Bronze and Black Turkeys for Your Christmas Feast
As Christmas approaches, many of us start planning the centre piece of our festive meal – the turkey. While there are various types of turkeys available, two unique varieties that often stand out are the Bronze turkey and the Black turkey.
As a seasoned butcher, I’m here to explain the physical differences between these two types of birds and how these differences can impact your Christmas lunch preparations.
Bronze Turkey:
Our legendary Bronze Turkey’s are supplied by Starveall Turkeys, Starveall Farm, Upton, Buckinghamshire and are slow reared, to the highest welfare standards
The turkeys at Starveall farm are kept in smaller flocks allowing to keep an eye on every bird. They are free to graze on fresh grass (to supplement their diet), forage for insects, dust-bathe, or scratch around and do whatever they want, all day long.
At night, they are safe and secure in spacious, straw-filled barns, where there is natural light, fresh straw every day, and plenty of food and water.
On the farm the birds are dry-plucked and hand finished and then, for that extra succulent flavour, they are hung for 10-14 days. Finally they are boxed, complete with pop-up timer and recipe leaflet, ready for your collection.
The history of the Bronze Turkey is a fascinating journey through time and agriculture, deeply rooted in both American and European farming traditions.
This breed, known for its distinctive bronze-colored plumage, has a rich heritage that begins in the Americas.
Native to North America, wild turkeys were first domesticated by indigenous peoples thousands of years ago. These turkeys were significantly different from the domesticated turkeys we know today.
European explorers in the 16th and 17th centuries encountered these birds and brought them back to Europe, where they quickly became popular.
In Europe, particularly in England, these American turkeys were bred with various local breeds. This crossbreeding eventually led to the development of the Bronze Turkey, named for its unique shimmering bronze-like sheen.
The breed was prized for its size, hardiness, and the quality of its meat, making it a favorite among farmers and poultry enthusiasts.
Throughout the 18th and 19th centuries, the Bronze Turkey became a staple in both American and European poultry farming.
It was the preferred breed for the Thanksgiving holiday in the United States, symbolizing abundance and tradition. The breed was known for its ability to forage and thrive in diverse environments, making it a versatile choice for small and large farms alike.
However, like many heritage breeds, the Bronze Turkey faced competition from commercial breeds in the 20th century.
The advent of industrial farming favored the Broad Breasted White turkey, which was bred for its rapid growth and larger size, suitable for mass production. This shift led to a decline in the popularity of Bronze Turkeys.
Despite this, the Bronze Turkey has seen a resurgence in popularity in recent years. This renewed interest is largely driven by the sustainable farming movement and the growing demand for diverse, heritage breeds.
These turkeys are now raised by small-scale farmers and enthusiasts who appreciate their historical significance, robustness, and the quality of their meat.
Today, the Bronze Turkey is celebrated not only for its culinary qualities but also for its role in agricultural heritage. It stands as a symbol of traditional farming practices and biodiversity in livestock.
The breed continues to be a favorite during the Thanksgiving season in the U.S., embodying a rich history that spans continents and centuries.
Bronze turkeys are known for their striking appearance. They have dark, iridescent feathers that shimmer with shades of bronze, green, and copper. Their feathers give them a regal and majestic appearance that is sure to catch your eye.Bronze turkeys are typically larger than the average turkey, making them an excellent choice for larger gatherings. They can range from 12 to 30 pounds or even more, depending on your needs.
Bronze turkeys are renowned for their rich and flavorful meat. They have a slightly stronger taste compared to other turkey breeds, thanks to their larger size and well-developed muscles. The meat is succulent, juicy, and has a pronounced turkey flavor that many find irresistible.
Cooking Tips:
When cooking a Bronze turkey for your Christmas lunch, it’s essential to consider its size. Roasting is the most common method, and you’ll want to calculate your cooking time based on the bird’s weight. A general rule of thumb is to roast at 325°F (165°C), allowing around 15 minutes per pound. Use a meat thermometer to ensure the internal temperature reaches 165°F (74°C) for safe consumption.
Black Turkey:
The Black Turkey, also known as the Black Spanish or Norfolk Black, boasts a history that intertwines European and American agricultural practices. Its origins trace back to North America, where the Aztecs had domesticated a similar variety before European explorers arrived. Contrary to its Norfolk Black moniker, this turkey did not originate in Norfolk, England. Instead, it was likely brought to Europe by Spanish traders from the Americas.
Once in Europe, the Black Turkey quickly gained popularity, especially in Spain and England. In England, it became known as the Norfolk Black, named after a region where it was extensively bred. The breed was prized for its hardiness and the quality of its meat, making it a valuable addition to European poultry.
The Black Turkey is distinguished by its lustrous black plumage, often exhibiting a green or bronze sheen. As a heritage breed, it retains many historic characteristics that modern, industrially-bred turkeys lack.
These birds are known for their robustness, excellent foraging ability, and strong mothering instincts.
However, the rise of industrial farming and the preference for broad-breasted white turkeys led to a decline in the Black Turkey’s popularity.
It wasn’t until a resurgence of interest in sustainable farming and heritage breeds that the Black Turkey began to make a comeback. This renewed interest is driven by both sustainable farming practices and consumer desire for diverse, traditional breeds.
Culturally and historically, the Black Turkey holds significant importance. It is emblematic of traditional farming methods and represents a crucial part of agricultural heritage.
In the United States, the movement to preserve genetic diversity in livestock has brought heritage breeds like the Black Turkey into the spotlight.
Today, the Black Turkey is primarily raised by small-scale farmers and heritage poultry enthusiasts. It is celebrated for its distinctive characteristics and has become a feature in farm-to-table restaurants and local markets.
Additionally, the breed plays a crucial role in conservation efforts aimed at maintaining the genetic diversity of poultry. The Black Turkey, thus, stands as a testament to the rich tapestry of agricultural history and the ongoing efforts to preserve traditional livestock breeds.
Black turkeys tend to be smaller than Bronze turkeys, making them an ideal choice for smaller gatherings. They typically range from 8 to 18 pounds.
The meat of Black turkeys is considered exceptionally flavorful, with a deeper, earthier taste compared to commercial turkey breeds. Their traditional breeding methods and more active lifestyle contribute to the distinct flavor.
Cooking Tips:
Cooking a Black turkey for your Christmas lunch is similar to cooking other turkeys. Roasting is the preferred method, and you can use the same temperature guidelines as for Bronze turkeys. Remember to use a meat thermometer to ensure the meat reaches a safe internal temperature of 165°F (74°C).
Conclusion:
Whether you choose a Bronze turkey or a Black turkey for your Christmas feast, both varieties offer unique and delicious flavors that will delight your guests. Consider the size of your gathering, your personal taste preferences, and the cooking time needed when making your choice. Whichever you decide on, a well-prepared turkey will undoubtedly be the star of your holiday table, bringing joy and warmth to your festive celebration.
Our Christmas ordering is op[en until Saturday 9th December, so why not visit our online shop boy Clicking HERE
Happy cooking and a Merry Christmas!
